Logo for Piano Play It

Comments for
Slurs And Ties

Click here to add your own comments

The Difference between a Slur and a Tie
by: Ido Ronen from www.piano-play-it.com

Many students get confused between slurs and ties. Let me try to make it clearer for you.
The first thing you should do when you see a curved line is recognize whether it is a slur or a tie.

How do we distinguish between a slur and a tie?

A tie is a curved line that connects the heads of two consecutive notes with the same pitch. So, if the notes have different pitches, then the curved line is a slur - not a tie.

In your question you mentioned "2 different notes have both a slur and a tie".
If you mean that the notes are different (having different pitches), then the curved line is not a tie; it is a slur.

When you see a tie, it means you should play only the first note. The key is held down and its duration is the length of the two notes.

When you see a slur it means you should play all the notes. The slur indicates you should play in a Legato manner.

Now, let?s see two examples that will help to understand two confusing possibilities:




In example 1 you can see two curved lines. Both of them are slurs.

a) The smaller one connects E to F. It is not a tie because the notes have a different pitch. This slur marks the legato between E and F.
b) The bigger slur indicates the beginning and the ending of a musical phrase. (It does not neccesary mean you have to play Legato through the whole musical line but realize that you're playing a complete musical sentence.)

In example 2 there are two curved lines. The smaller one is a tie, and the bigger one is a slur.

a) The tie connects E and E. We see it as a tie because it connects the heads of two consecutive notes with the same pitch.
b) The slur which connects E and F indicates the legato between these two (different) notes.

Remember:
A tie connects the heads of two notes with the same pitch. You should basically play only the first note, and hold the key down for the duration of both notes.

A slur has two major meanings ? Framing a musical phrasing and legato. In both cases you should play all the notes you see.

Now, go back to the page about musical phrasing, and read it again. You may find it clearer now.

I hope you are not confused anymore...
Don't hesitate to ask further questions!

Ido from www.piano-play-it.com

Click here to add your own comments

Join in and write your own page! It's easy to do. How?
Simply click here to return to Piano FAQs Question or Answer

Return to Slurs And Ties



Join Our Facebook Group...

"Your entire site is simply fantastic. I really loved it. Now I am learning the basics of piano by myself, with your really great help. Thank you very much!"

Jaime C. from Brazil



The Rocket Piano Ultimate Piano Learning Kit

Learn all about how your brain processes information, and how to maximise your piano practice time. (Nine out of ten people are absolutely floored by this secret!)

The Ultimate Piano Learning Kit
Check It Out Now!



"I only started to play about six weeks ago but the last hour of watching your videos about chord progressions has been something of a revelation. You're brilliant!!!!"

Stephen Roberts from U.S.A



"I'm a beginning keyboardplayer and your video's are an excellent guide. You're absolute not in a hurry, and take time to explain. I'm sure i'll follow all your lessons to get the hang of playing the piano/keyboard!"

Wouter E. from the Netherlands



"Thanks for all your work ( tuto and others ). You're doing a really great job, You're the best internet teacher I know."

Anthony Hassen Cohen from France



"I really appreciate what you do for piano lovers and i'll let everyone interested i know to come visit your website and see how magnificent it is organized and how much you are really helpful to us beginners."

Mohamed B. from Egypt



"Thank you so much for all these piano lessons! You really make it easier for some of us who always wanted to play piano and have no musical experience."

Luis S. from the U.S.A



"Today I watched your video on "how to play piano by ear" and was totally amazed at how well you teach. I wish I lived close by, I would hire you for lessons."

Douglas Grendahl from U.S.A



"Thank you for your lessons. I took piano lessons as a kid, and I've dabbled off and on for years. My music teacher taught me how to read music and hit all the notes, but I never felt like I was playing for real. I always felt like I was going through the motions, like a machine. Your lessons have changed that, so thanks."

Joshua White from U.S.A





[?] Subscribe To
This Site

XML RSS
Add to Google
Add to My Yahoo!
Add to My MSN
Add to Newsgator
Subscribe with Bloglines



Enjoy This Site?
Then why not use the button below, to add us to your favorite bookmarking service?

Copyright piano-play-it.com © 2008-2011.